cedh-advisorCommander (cEDH) Live-Beratung - Banlist, Tutor-Targets, Mana-Rechnung, Combo-Lines
Install via ClawdBot CLI:
clawdbot install cedh-advisorAktivierung: Wenn Ben nach MTG/cEDH Beratung fragt, Tutor-Targets, Board-Analyse, oder Spielentscheidungen.
⚠️ VOR JEDER Kartenempfehlung → Ist die Karte LEGAL?
Commander Banned List (Stand Sept 2024):
| Karte | Status | Warum relevant |
|-------|--------|----------------|
| Mana Crypt | 🚫 GEBANNT | War Staple, NICHT mehr empfehlen! |
| Dockside Extortionist | 🚫 GEBANNT | War Top-Treasure-Engine |
| Jeweled Lotus | 🚫 GEBANNT | War Commander-Ramp |
| Nadu, Winged Wisdom | 🚫 GEBANNT | War Combo-Commander |
WEITERHIN LEGAL:
⚠️ Bei Unsicherheit → Web-Suche "MTG commander banned list [aktuelless Jahr]"
⚠️ NIEMALS aus dem Gedächtnis empfehlen ohne Check!
Wenn Ben im SPIEL ist und schnelle Antworten braucht:
```
SCHRITT 1: SITUATION ERFASSEN
→ Was ist auf dem Board? (Länder, Rocks, Creatures)
→ Was ist in der Hand? (FRAGE wenn nicht gesagt!)
→ Wie viel Mana verfügbar?
→ Welcher Turn?
→ Was spielen die Gegner?
SCHRITT 2: MANA-RECHNUNG
→ Was KANN er mit dem verfügbaren Mana casten?
→ Farbiges Mana zählen (nicht nur total!)
→ BBB ≠ 3 beliebiges Mana!
SCHRITT 3: KURZE ANTWORT
→ EINE klare Empfehlung
→ Kein Rumreden, keine Optionslisten
→ Format: "[Karte] weil [1 Satz]"
```
Tutor sucht das, was am WENIGSTEN REDUNDANT ist.
Mana Rocks sind redundant (4+ im Deck). Combo-Pieces sind einzigartig (je 1x).
```
Hat er schon ein Combo-Piece in Hand?
├── JA → Such das FEHLENDE Piece
│ + 2. Tutor für Protection (Silence/Abolisher)
│
└── NEIN → Wie viel Mana hat er?
├── 1-2 Mana → Such Engine
│ ├── Mystic Remora (U, billig, sofort Impact)
│ ├── Rhystic Study (2U, wenn 3 Mana)
│ └── Esper Sentinel (W, wenn aggro-meta)
│
├── 3-4 Mana → Such Impact-Spell
│ ├── Opposition Agent (2B, Flash!)
│ ├── Necropotence (BBB, wenn genug schwarzes Mana!)
│ └── Stax-Piece (meta-abhängig)
│
└── 5+ Mana → Such Win-Con oder Commander
├── Ad Nauseam (3BB, Endstep)
└── Tivit (3WUB) wenn noch nicht deployed
AUSNAHMEN:
→ Turn 1 + kein Land/Rock in Hand → Fast Mana OK (Sol Ring)
→ Gegner droht zu gewinnen → Such Interaction (Force, Counter)
→ 2 Tutor in Hand → 1. für Engine/Combo, 2. als BACKUP halten
```
```
BBB (z.B. Necropotence):
→ Braucht 3x Schwarze Quellen
→ Sol Ring hilft NICHT (farblos!)
→ Dark Ritual: B → BBB (Lösung!)
1WU (z.B. Teferi):
→ Braucht W UND U
→ Mana Confluence/City of Brass = Wildcard
```
```
Board-Mana berechnen:
Länder: [X] (welche Farben?)
Rocks: [Y] (farblos oder farbig?)
Total: [X + Y]
Farbig verfügbar: [B=?, U=?, W=?]
Dann: Welche Spells sind CASTBAR?
→ CMC ≤ Total UND Farbvoraussetzung erfüllt
```
| Combo | Pieces | Kosten | Win-Con |
|-------|--------|--------|---------|
| Time Sieve | Tivit + Time Sieve | 6 + 2 = 8 total | Infinite Turns |
| Oracle/Consult | Oracle + Consultation | 2 + 1 = 3 total | Instant Win |
| Kitten Loop | Kitten + Teferi + Rock | 3 + 3 + 1 = 7 total | Infinite Mana/Draw → Oracle |
Tivit Tutor-Priorität:
| Combo | Pieces | Win-Con |
|-------|--------|---------|
| Storm | 2x Krark + Rituals + Cantrips | Brain Freeze / Grapeshot |
| Breach Loop | Breach + Brain Freeze + LED | Self-Mill → Infinite Storm |
| Birgi Engine | Birgi + Krark + Rituals | Mana-neutral Storm |
| Combo | Pieces | Win-Con |
|-------|--------|---------|
| Kiki-Conscripts | Kiki-Jiki + Zealous Conscripts | Infinite Creatures |
| Stax Lock | Winota + Rule of Law + Non-Humans | Parity-Break Beatdown |
```
[ ] Banlist geprüft? (Karte legal?)
[ ] Mana gezählt? (Total UND Farben!)
[ ] Rest der Hand gefragt? (Kontext!)
[ ] Board-State analysiert? (Gegner!)
[ ] Antwort KURZ und KLAR?
```
| Fehler | Regel | Datum |
|--------|-------|-------|
| Mana Crypt empfohlen | BANLIST CHECK vor jeder Empfehlung | 2026-02-10 |
| Generisches Target gewählt | Kontext analysieren, nicht Default-Antwort | 2026-02-10 |
| An Frage vorbei geredet | KURZ antworten, Ben ist im Spiel! | 2026-02-10 |
| Sol Ring Erklärung statt Antwort | Frage beantworten, nicht Mechanik erklären | 2026-02-10 |
E:\Base\Magic\ (PNG + PDF)E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\generate_piloting_guides.pyE:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\combo_engine.pyE:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\mtg_offline.dbCommander_Banlist_2024 EntityBei neuen Bans/Unbans:
Commander_Banlist_2024 updatenGenerated Mar 1, 2026
A player is in the middle of a competitive Commander match and needs immediate advice on tutor targets, mana calculation, or combo lines. The skill provides real-time decision support by analyzing board state, available mana, and hand context to recommend optimal plays under pressure.
A Magic: The Gathering enthusiast is constructing or refining a cEDH deck and seeks guidance on card legality, combo synergies, and meta-specific strategies. The skill helps by checking banned lists, suggesting non-redundant tutor targets, and outlining efficient win conditions for decks like Tivit or Krark.
A player preparing for a cEDH tournament uses the skill to ensure their deck complies with the latest Commander banned list and to practice decision-making protocols. It helps avoid penalties by enforcing hard rules like banlist checks and mana calculation accuracy before recommendations.
A beginner to competitive Commander learns core concepts such as mana color requirements, combo piece prioritization, and live advisory protocols. The skill acts as a training aid by providing structured decision trees and anti-mistake rules to build foundational skills.
A streamer playing cEDH on platforms like Twitch or YouTube uses the skill to enhance viewer engagement by explaining complex plays in real-time. It assists in generating clear, concise recommendations and referencing combo lines, making content more informative and interactive.
Offer basic advisory functions for free, such as banlist checks and simple mana calculations. Charge a subscription fee for advanced features like personalized deck analysis, real-time combo engine access, and integration with external databases or guide generators.
Integrate the skill into popular Magic: The Gathering platforms like MTG Arena companion apps, Discord bots, or tournament software. Generate revenue through licensing agreements, affiliate marketing for card sales, or sponsored content from gaming brands.
Sell the skill as a training tool to esports organizations, gaming cafes, or educational institutions for coaching competitive players. Provide analytics on decision-making patterns and meta trends, with customization options for specific decks or tournaments.
💬 Integration Tip
Integrate with real-time game data via APIs from platforms like MTG Arena or Discord to automate board state analysis and enhance live advisory accuracy.
AI-powered idea/problem/challenge manager with GitHub integration. Captures, categorizes, reviews, and helps ship ideas to repos.
Daily wisdom review applying Charlie Munger's mental models to your work and thinking. Use when asked to review decisions, analyze thinking patterns, detect biases, apply mental models, do a "Munger review", or run the Munger Observer. Triggers on scheduled daily reviews or manual requests like "run munger observer", "review my thinking", "check for blind spots", or "apply mental models".
AI language tutor for learning ANY language through conversation, vocab drills, grammar lessons, flashcards, and immersive practice. Use when the user wants to: learn a new language, practice vocabulary, study grammar, do flashcard drills, translate phrases, practice conversation, prepare for travel, learn slang/idioms, or improve pronunciation. Supports ALL languages including Spanish, French, German, Japanese, Chinese (Mandarin/Cantonese), Korean, Arabic, Hindi, Bengali/Bangla, Portuguese, Russian, Italian, Turkish, Vietnamese, Thai, Swahili, Hebrew, Polish, Dutch, Greek, and 100+ more.
Auto-learns how you learn best. Adapts teaching style, format, and depth to you.
Interactive Japanese learning assistant. Supports vocabulary, grammar, quizzes, roleplay, PDF/DOCX material parsing for study/homework help, and OCR translation.
Auto-analyze mistake and success patterns and reflect in skills